Issue Information
Impact of remittances on healthcare utilisation and expenditure in developing countries : a systematic review
Awojobi Oladayo Nathaniel
Abstract
Background
The poor and low-income earners used remittances to access healthcare services because most of them are not covered by private or government health insurance schemes.The money sent by migrant workers from abroad to their family members, relatives and friends serves as social protection, especially in developing countries where there are no standardised social protection programmes.
Objective
This review assesses the impact of remittances on healthcare utilisation and expenditure in developing countries.
Methods
A systematic search for relevant literature was conducted online for studies published between 2002 and 2018.
Results
The inclusion criteria of the study were met by 7 out of the 135 studies searched electronically. The studies conducted in Africa, Asia, Europe and Latin America, found that remittances contributed toincreased healthcare access, utilisation and expenditures. However, the degrees of these impacts were limited among the studies except in Armenia, where remittances significantly increased healthcare utilisation.
Conclusion
Although remittances can not serve as an alternative to formal healthcare insurance schemes, they can serve as a short-term measure in healthcare utilisation in developing countries. It is the responsibility of governments at all levels to formulate health policies that will embrace universal healthcare coverage for all citizens.
Factors contributing to medication administration errors and barriers to self-reporting among nurses : a review of literature
Aimable Nkurunziza, Geldine Chironda, Madeleine Mukeshimana, Marie Claire Uwamahoro, Marie Louise Umwangange, Flavien Ngendahayo
Abstract
Background
Medication Administration Errors (MAEs) are common among nurses and can threaten all patients’ outcomes. Furthermore, MAEs are the leading cause of incidents in patient safety records worldwide.
Objective
To review the types of medication administration errors, factors contributing to MAEs and barriers to self-reporting among nurses.
Methods
A review of the literature was done and included original articles and grey literature from January 2011 until July 2017. An advanced search was done in Medline, HINARI, PubMed, CINAHL, Science direct, Google Scholar and gray literature using a Boolean combination of different keywords such as “medication administration error”, “adverse drugs reactions”, barriers and “self-reporting”.
Results
The 257 articles were eligible for review but only27 articles met the inclusion criteria. Types of MAEs mainly focused on seven rights (right patient, right drug, right dose, right time, right route, right reason and right documentation). With regards to the types of MAEs, the wrong time was most prevalent in this study. Being overworked was the main factor contributing to medication administration errors. The barriers to self-reporting during MAEs were dominated by fear of disciplinary action. Nurses’ characteristics such as age, experience, education, variations in how errors are defined and organizational factors such as power, distance and lack of reporting policies were found to be barriers to self-reporting. In addition to that, others were identified.
Conclusion
Globally, MAEs remain a pervasive problem among nurses. Contributing factors range from individual to organizational factors, and barriers to self-report are due to fear of legal action and punishment. There is a need to devise measures that will prevent these errors and to promote positive clinical outcomes of patients in healthcare settings.
Improving starting time in operating rooms of a tertiary hospital in Rwanda : a quality improvement project
Assumpta Yamuragiye, Faustin Ntirenganya, David Tumusiime, Mecthilde Mukangendo, Dawit T. Bisrat, Rex Wong
Abstract
Background
Delay in the first surgery start time at operating room (OR) could inevitably decrease utilization, lose very expensive OR resources, reduce satisfaction of patients and staff and potentially affect quality of patient care.
Objectives
This study utilized the Strategic Problem Solving (SPS) quality improvement approach to increase the percentage of first surgeries started on time at a tertiary hospital in Rwanda.
Methods
A pre- and post-intervention study was conducted between March 2016 and March 2017. The intervention included developing a policy on staff arrival time, training sessions on the policy and regular supervision of OR managers to ensure staff were arriving on time.
Results
Chi square tests were performed to analyze the pre- and post-intervention results. The percentage of first surgeries started on time significantly increased from 3% pre-intervention to 25% postintervention (P<0.001), average duration of delay decreased by 55 minutes (P<0.001) and the percentages of nurses, anesthetists and surgeon arrived on time also significantly increased (P<0.001).
Conclusion
The SPS approach can be useful in addressing the starting time of first surgery at OR. Support from the senior management team and buy-in from staff are essential. This project cannot eliminate confounding factors and the results cannot be generalizable to other settings. Longer term evaluation on sustainability is needed.
Synchronization of patient data among health facilities through electronic medical records system : a case study of Kabgayi District Hospital
Charité Niyitegeka, Thaoussi Uwera, Noel Korukire, Sani Nasiru, Innocent Hakizimana, Sunday François Xavier, Jean Paul Niyoyita, Pierre Claver Kayumba
Abstract
Background
The use of modern technology in healthcare system aims to increase the reliability, accessibility and productivity of delivered services. In most developing countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, Electronic Medical Records (EMRs) has been dominated by paper-based system. In Rwanda, EMRs started in 2011 with a baseline of 8% and reached 50% in 2017 within 516 health facilities, but patient data synchronization among health facilities is still a problem. The aim of this research was to identify factors hindering EMRs implementation and propose applied solutions.
Methods
A cross-sectional descriptive study design with qualitative and quantitative approach was used. A purposive method to select the research participants among the target population was also used.
Results
It was found that, despite the improvement of hospitals’ management and healthcare efficiency via EMRs system, factors affecting synchronization of patients’ data among health facilities still persist. The study also revealed the need for the interoperability in the integration of EMRs system among health facilities.
Conclusion
The OpenMRS EMR-based data synchronization can reduce gaps in HIV care. It avoids a duplication of patient identification number (PID) at the same health facility for more than one visit and missing data among health facilities. As part of implementable solutions for effective service delivery, cloud-based server and patient identification were suggested as solutions for much more success in Open MRS EMRs system.
Microbiological quality of Lactuca sativa (lettuce) salad vegetables sold in restaurants in Kigali, Rwanda
Claudine Umuhire
Abstract
Background
Salad which is served at restaurants in uncooked form can be source of bacterial contamination.
Aim
To assess the microbiological quality of lettuce (Lactuca sativa) salads sold in two restaurants in Kigali, Rwanda.
Methods
Lettuce samples were collected using aseptic techniques and immediately analysed using standard media for E. coli, Salmonella, Shigella and Staphyloccocus aureus besides total aerobic count.
Results
The number of total aerobic bacteria ranged from 1.15 x 104 to 2.87x104 cfu/ml for restaurant 1 and from 1.91x10 4 to 2.13x105cfu/ml for restaurant 2. Staphyloccoci count ranged from 3.6x10 2 to 1.173x103 cfu/ml for restaurant 1 and from 1.9 x102 to 3.2 x102 cfu/ml for restaurant 2. Gram negative bacteria count ranged from 8.3 x102 to 1.03 x105 cfu/ml for restaurant 1 and from 5.05 x102 to 2.30 x105 cfu/ml for restaurant 2. Salmonella and Shigella count ranged from 2.54x103 to 2.04x104 cfu/ml for restaurant 1 and from 3.65x103 to 2.5x104 cfu/ml for restaurant 2. E. coli was found in 75% of the sample from restaurant 1 and 100% of the sample from restaurant 2.
Conclusion
Improvement in hygiene is needed during preparation and handling of lettuce salad in these restaurants.
Hospital acquired infections in pediatrics unit at Butare University Teaching Hospital (CHUB)
Claude Bayingana, Augustin Sendegeya, Felix Habarugira, Caritas Mukumpunga, Francois Lyumugabe, Jules Ndoli
Abstract
Background
Hospital acquired infection (HAI) also called nosocomial infection is an infection acquired in hospital or other healthcare facilities. HAIs are a major public health problem all over the world, but particularly in developing nations and they are among the major causes of death and increased morbidity among hospitalized patients. It was found that HAI in sub-Saharan Africa is the major cause of illness and death in children.
Aim
The aim of this study was to provide knowledge on the prevalence of hospital acquired infection in pediatric unit of the University Teaching Hospital of Butare (Rwanda).
Methods
Hospital acquired infections surveillance method and definition of infections described by CDC/NHSN were used.
Results and conclusion
This study showed that the prevalence of HAI was very high (12.1 %) and the main bacteria causing NIs in pediatric unit were Kleblesiela pneumonia, followed by E. coli and Staphylococcus aureus. Low Respiratory HAIs were the most prevalent.
Indwelling urinary catheter placement and removal practices among surgical patients at Kigali University Teaching Hospital
Joselyne Mukantwari, Lilian Omondi, Donatilla Mukamana, Oluyinka Adejumo
Abstract
Background
Indwelling urinary Catheters (IUCs) are routinely used medical devices among patients undergoing surgery and their undue use is a risk factor for urinary tract infections (UTIs). The study aim was to assess IUCs placement and removal practices among patients undergoing surgery.
Methods
We carried out a cross-sectional study on 207 patients operated at Kigali University Teaching Hospital (KUTH). A pretested observation checklist (Cronbach : α=0.851) was used for data collection. The data were analyzed using SPSS version 20. Chi-square test was used to determine the association between patients’ characteristics and IUCs placement and removal.
Results
The IUC placement rate was 56.5% (n=117). There was significant association of IUCs use with gender, age, type and urgency of surgical procedures performed and the type of anesthesia used. Appropriate indication for IUC placement was established in 95.7% patients (n=112). Although 99.1% (n=116) patients were discharged from theatre with IUCs in situ, only 56.5% (n=66) had documented removal instructions.
Conclusion
This study established that IUCs use is common and justified in surgery. However, lack of removal instruction was found to be a challenge. Therefore, the authors recommend patients’ re-evaluation for post-surgery IUC need and its early removal where inappropriate to prevent CAUTIs and other complications.
Profile of injuries among sitting volleyball players with disabilities in Rwanda
Assuman Nuhu, Ben Honoré Nishimwe, Jean Bosco Nteziryayo, Aimée Flora Nyirahabimana, Jackline Starehe, Anne Kumurenzi, Jean Baptiste Sagahutu
Abstract
Background
Sports injuries are some of the risk of paralympics sport. Injuries are somewhat high compared with injury rates in able-bodied athletes. Injuries might have an impact on the participation and future health. It is paramount to investigate sports specific injuries to eliminate associated risks.
Aim
To identify patterns of injuries among sitting volleyball players in Rwanda.
Methods
A prospective quantitative study was conducted among 158 sitting volleyball players competing in the 2013-2014 season. The research team composed by physiotherapists used the data collection process following the consensus on injury definitions and data collection procedures. The ethical clearance and permission were obtained from relevant bodies. ANOVA or the Mann–Whitney U-test were used for continuous variables while Chi-square or Fisher’s exact tests were used for categorical variables.
Results
All the 158 players aged 25±6 years participated in the study ; with male predominance (66.5%). Fifty-eight players (37%) sustained at least one injury. Nearly half of injuries (n=43) were mild, consistent for both male and female. There was no statistical difference in the patterns of injuries comparing male and female participants.
Conclusion
Sitting volleyball players with disability in Rwanda sustained a high prevalence of injuries. The fingers, hands and wrists were the most injured body parts. However, the health and integrative advantages should outweigh the risk of adverse effects associated with participation in sports such as injuries.
Occupational health risks associated with medical waste management practices among health professionals working in three district hospitals in Rwanda
Jotham Karenzi, Noel Korukire, David Basheija, Innocent Hakizimana, Marie Claire Ineza, Mecthilde Mukangendo, Isabelle Kayitesi, Emelyne Umutoni Cishahayo, Liliane Birasa, Charite Niyitegeka, Abela Anne M’Lurhe
Abstract
Background
Proper healthcare waste management is crucial to minimize the exposure of health professionals, patients, and the public in general, and to reduce the pollution of the environment in particular. In Rwanda, scientific documents on occupational health risks resulting from medical waste management practices among healthcare workers are currently rare.
Aim
This study aimed to explore occupational health risks associated with medical waste management practices among health professionals in the Rwandan context.
Method
A cross-sectional study design was used. The study used both quantitative and qualitative methods. The respondents were composed of health professionals (medical doctors, nurses, and paramedical staff) from the district hospital and six key informants. We used questionnaire, interview guide, and observation checklists as research instruments. We performed descriptive statistics to analyze the quantitative data. Also, qualitative data were analyzed using narrative analysis method.
Results
The findings revealed that 56.5 % of respondents from Kibagabaga hospital, 26.8% from Masaka and 49.3% from Muhima Hospital reported that they experienced occupational health risks related to inadequate medical waste management at their workplaces, and some of those risks include risk of infection and physical injuries.
Conclusion
This study concludes that health professionals working in health facilities in Rwanda are exposed to the risks resulting from poor medical waste management practices. Thus, the study recommends putting more emphasis on raising awareness of staff towards risks resulting from poor medical waste management practices.
Kangaroo mother care in the community : practices in southern Rwanda
Leonard Ntwari Nyagasare, Louise Cauwelier, Assumpta Kayinamura Mwali, Luk Cannoodt
Abstract
Background
The World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines recommend practicing KMC (Kangaroo Mother Care) continuously for weeks after discharge of preterm newborns. However, little is known about KMC practices in the community in Rwanda and other African countries.Therefore, this study sought to assess KMC practices in Southern Rwanda, primarily after hospitalization and identify barriers to KMC in the community.
Methods
A cross-sectional study was performed with data collected through a survey among 124 caregivers of preterm infants and Community Health Workers. The Statistical Package for the Social Sciences SPSS version 22 was used to analyze the data.
Results
Among all caregivers interviewed, 86.7% confirmed that they practiced KMC, both in the hospital (KABUTARE District Hospital) as well as after discharge, but there is a large variation in practice time and place. KMC is practiced more during daytime. Working in the fields and lack of support to the caregivers are reported most frequently as barriers to practice KMC in the community.
Conclusion
KMC-practice is still sub-optimal in Rwanda. Special attention should be directed towards KMCpractice at night and towards the reported obstacles of practicing KMC in the community, e.g. working in the field, lack of support and equipment, difficulties to sleep and health problems.
Local authorities’ attitude towards people with mental illness in Musanze District, Rwanda
Vedaste Baziga, Augustin Gasovya, Fauste Uwingabire
Abstract
Introduction
Mental illnesses (MIs) are currently contributing to the worldwide burden of disease and they are among 10 main causes of disability on worldwide. In addition, mental Health care users are among the people most stigmatized by the general population which includes local leaders.
Methods
The design used for conducting this study was quantitative and cross-sectional survey and the study was conducted in Muhoza sector of Musanze District in Rwanda. The tool used to correct data was self-report questionnaire that included socio-demographic variables (gender, age, experience and level of education), level of contact scale and community attitudes towards mental illness - Swedish version (CAMI-S). In this study self-report questionnaire was provided to the local authorities in Muhoza sector (n=123, N=174). Data analysis was done using a statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) version 22.
Results
Findings from the current study revealed negative stereotypical attitudes among local authorities towards people with mental illness. The participants’ total score on the CAMI-S was ranging between 24% and 81%. In addition, the study revealed some contradictions and neutral responses. Less negative stereotypical attitudes were found among participants who have university and secondary education levels than participants with primary education and those who have not completed primary school. In addition, participants with more experience in local government system reflected less negative stereotypical attitudes than participants who are less experienced in local government system. This study showed a negative correlation between level of contact and community attitudes towards mental illness.
Conclusion
Local authorities in a selected sector of Musanze District, hold negative stereotypical attitudes towards people with mental disorders. However, the extent of contradiction within participant responses suggests social desirability bias. Also, there is association between negative stereotypical attitudes and the level of education and experience. Finally, the results suggest that familiarity has a mediating effect on negative stereotypical attitudes.
Factors associated with childhood diarrhea in Rwanda : a secondary data analysis of the Rwanda demographic and health survey 2014-15
Malachie Tuyizere, Theogene Nyandwi, Amos Habimana, Cyprien Munyanshongore
Abstract
Background
Diarrheal diseases remain an important cause of morbidity among children, particularly in children under five years old, in low- and middle-income countries where it causes nearly 1.7 billion cases every year.
Methods
We used a quantitative cross-sectional design. This study aimed to explore the determinants of child diarrhea among under five-year children in Rwanda. A deep analysis of the 2014- 2015 Rwanda Demographic and Health Survey (RDHS), with multivariate logistic regression, using stata13 was performed. The 2014-2015 Survey was the fifth standard national survey, implemented by the National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda (NISR) in a period of six months from November 2014 to April 2015.
Results
A sample of 2841 children under five years old were included. Chi-square test and logistic regression were performed. A significance level of 0.05 at 95% CI was considered. Child age and wealth index showed a strong association with diarrhea. Children in the age groups of 6-11, 12-23, 24-35 months were at higher risk of diarrhea than children aged 48-59 months, OR : 5.0 [3.1-8.2], P-value : 0.001 ; OR : 7.6, CI [4.7-12.2], P-value : 0.001 ; OR:3.8 [2.3-6.2], P-value : 0.001 respectively. Moreover, children from poorest and poorer families were twice more at risk of diarrhea than children from richest families. OR : 2, CI [1.3-2.9], P-value : 0.001.
Conclusion
The study concluded that low wealth index, and child age less than 35 months were important risks for under-five child diarrhea.
Community health workers’ attitude towards people with mental illness : potential challenge of maternal mental health services in a selected health centre, Ruhengeri Hospital in Rwanda
Vedaste Baziga, Augustin Gasovya, Fauste Uwingabire
Abstract
Introduction
Integration of mental health services into non psychiatric health care facilities from community level was recommended by the world health organization (WHO) in 1984 to improve the quality of mental health services provided to the local population. Community Health Workers (CHWs) have an important role to play for the implementation of WHO recommendation of integration especially at the community level. Research objectives were to : Describe attitude among CHWstowards people with a mental illness and explore relationships between socio-demographic variables and CHWs’ attitude towards people with mental illness in Muhoza health center/Ruhengeri hospital in Rwanda.
Methods
In this study, a quantitative descriptive cross-sectional design was used to conduct a research among CHWs operating under Muhoza health centre/ Ruhengeri hospital in Rwanda. A selfreport questionnaire was used to collect data on a sample of 138. Questionnaire consisted of sociodemographic variables and two sections that include level of contact (LOC) and the Community Attitude towards Mental Illness-Swedish version (CAMI-S). The statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) version 22 was used to analyze data.
Results
Findings showed negative attitude among community health workers in regards to people with mental illness (MI). The participants’ total score on the CAMI-S was ranging between 25% and 87%. This study revealed that participants with lower level of education and less experienced as CHWs reflected higher negative attitude in regards of people with mental illness than participants with higher level education and more experienced. Also, results from this study indicated that increase in LOC correlates with decrease in fear and avoidance towards people with mental illness.
Conclusion
Community health workers in a selected Health Centre/ Ruhengeri Hospital, in Rwanda hold negative attitudes towards people mentally ill. Also, there is association between negative stereotypes towards people mentally ill and the level of education and experience. Familiarity has a mediating effect on negative attitudes hold by community health workers in regards to people mentally ill.
M-health tools utilization of tele-home healthcare services for diabetes management among youth in Kigali City
Jean de Dieu Uwimana, Jacqueline Nyirandegeya, Emile Nisingizwe
Abstract
Background
Self-care of diabetes for youth requires a daily self-active participation, which is complex and demanding. Effective patient engagement through technology tools may bring about compliance to healthcare 24 hours/ 7 days which minimises the diabetes complications and clinicians overload.
Objective
This study aimed to assess M-health tools utilization of tele-home healthcare services for diabetes management among youth in Kigali City.
Method
This cross-sectional study was conducted among the Rwanda Diabetes Association members. The study populations were youth diabetic patients residing in Kigali city. With simple random sampling, self-administered questionnaire was used to collect data for 122 participants. The raw data was entered into the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS : 20) to perform descriptive and inferential statistics in data analysis.
Results
The mobile telephone is highly used in healthcare by participants (≥80%) with its functions such as Short Message Services, and the voice call is more useful (≥87%). Furthermore, occupation and education level of diabetic youth do not have significance influence (p=0.825 and p=0.751) over the use of a mobile telephone in healthcare. Radios and televisions are mostly used in healthcare education (93.5%).
Conclusions
Tele-home healthcare is practised in Rwanda but dominated by store and forward system. Mobile telephone, radio and television are mostly used whereas emails and social media are slowly used.